Tuesday, July 10, 2007

There’s little sympathy in Santa Ana for the bus drivers

By Jennifer Delson, Times Staff Writer
July 10, 2007

Three days into a strike by Orange County bus drivers, the walkout is resonating in Santa Ana with an urgency unfelt in neighboring cities.

Here in the county’s civic core, low-paid immigrant workers say they depend on public transportation not only to get to work but to travel to the grocery store, take children to health clinics and to keep basic appointments.

And finding sympathy here for striking drivers, some of whom earn more than $20 an hour, is a tall order.


On Monday, workers began long commutes riding bicycles, walking or bargaining for rides with unlicensed cabbies who have spotted the sudden business opportunity.

Experts say Santa Ana fits the profile of a city dependent on public transportation. In 2004, the Rockefeller Institute of Government, the public policy research arm of the State University of New York, singled out Santa Ana as the city with the greatest level of “urban hardship” in the United States. High rents and low wages factor into that distinction.

Santa Ana remains a magnet for new immigrants, and 10% of city residents — double the state average — rely on public transportation, according to census data. The Orange County Transportation Authority reports that two-thirds of its bus riders are Latino.

At the corner of Pine and Main streets, where unlicensed taxi drivers typically wait for customers willing to pay $20 a head for rides to Tijuana, even drivers commiserated with customers they’re now driving to local destinations.

“I couldn’t even force myself to charge anyone,” said driver Angel Benji, who transports clients in a late-model green van.

“I had a woman here crying that she would lose her job in Huntington Beach if she couldn’t get there, and she had no money. She only makes $5 an hour as a nanny for some rich people,” Benji said. “This is the sort of person affected by this strike — the poorest of the poor. How can we show compassion for a bus driver making $20 an hour?”

One bus driver, Benjamin C. Garcia, said he and his co-workers were just trying to keep up with the cost of living in Orange County.

“We are not asking to live in luxury. We are asking for what we need,” said Garcia, 39. “Everything is going up. Gas, food and rent. We just want to be treated fairly.”

In downtown Santa Ana, that message did little to placate those who rely on buses.

Hilda Cuellar, who works at Hugo’s Beauty Salon, said she usually has 45 to 60 customers a weekend. She said that last weekend, with the strike in progress, she had only 12. Other business owners said foot traffic was alarmingly light on the weekend.

“People are calling to ask if there’s any bus to our shop,” Cuellar said. “I can’t give them any good news. It’s very frustrating. These people [bus drivers] want more money for their jobs, and we are hurting here. We have no customers and we still have to pay our bills, our taxes, and the people don’t care.”

Angel Paredes, 40, said he walked 45 minutes to South Main Street in Santa Ana, where he got a ride with a friend to a warehouse job about five miles away. He had planned for another friend to pick him up from work at 4:30 p.m. and take him to a second job at a fast-food chain. Paredes said he works 11 hours a day and makes about $500 a week.

Over the weekend, he and his wife skipped their usual grocery shopping because of the bus strike. Walking and hauling their groceries back home would have been too much, he said.

Nazario Garibay left his Santa Ana home at 5 a.m. to get to Orange, but by 7 had given up on getting to his gardening job, which pays $60 a day.

“It’s getting harder and harder to just work in this country,” said Garibay, 52, who vowed to return to his native Mexico if the bus strike continued.

Mario Gomez Garcia, 28, paid an unlicensed taxi driver $15 for a ride to Brea, where he earns $8 an hour shaping and cutting palm trees.

“I know that I’m giving the first two hours of salary to the cab driver, but it’s better than losing the job,” Gomez Garcia said. “Without a car, without a bus, we are really lost in this region.”


jennifer.delson@latimes.com

(INFOBOX BELOW)

Routes in service during strike

Fifty of the county’s 81 bus routes are shut down during the bus strike, which started Sunday. Thirty routes are operating normally, but Route 43, the busiest line, has been shortened and leaves from Fullerton instead of La Habra. See route maps at http://www.octa.net

Route no.: Origin and destination, route

43: Fullerton - Costa Mesa via Harbor Blvd.

75: Tustin - Newport Beach via Harvard Ave./Jamboree Rd.

131: Yorba Linda - Orange via Lakeview Ave./Riverdale Ave./Tustin Ave.

147: Brea - Santa Ana via Birch St./Brea Blvd./Harbor Blvd./Raymond Ave./Haster St./La Veta Ave.

164: Seal Beach - Westminster via Seal Beach Blvd./Lampson Ave./Edwards St.

172: Huntington Beach - Costa Mesa via Main St./Garfield Ave./Ellis Ave./MacArthur Blvd./Sunflower St.

173: Huntington Beach - Costa Mesa via Atlanta Ave./Hamilton Ave./Victoria St./Orange Ave./Fair Dr./Bear St.

175: Irvine via Yale Ave./Campus Drive

188: Laguna Hills - Irvine via Moulton Pkwy./Irvine Center Dr./Alton Pkwy./Ridge Route

191/191A: Mission Viejo - San Clemente via Rancho Viejo Rd./Camino Capistrano/El Camino Real

193: San Clemente via Camino de los Mares/Camino Vera Cruz/Avenida Pico

212: Irvine - San Juan Capistrano Express via 405 Freeway

216: San Juan Capistrano - Costa Mesa Express via 405 Freeway

410: Anaheim Canyon Metrolink Station - Anaheim via Tustin Ave./La Palma Ave.

411: Anaheim Canyon Metrolink Station - Canyon Corporate Center via Coronado St./La Palma Ave.

430: Anaheim Metrolink Station/Amtrak Station – Anaheim Resort Area via Katella Ave./Harbor Blvd./Ball Rd.

453: Orange Transportation Center - St. Joseph’s Hospital via Chapman Ave./Main St./La Veta Ave.

454: Orange Transportation Center - Garden Grove via Chapman Ave./Metropolitian Dr.

462: The Depot at Santa Ana - Civic Center via Santa Ana Blvd./Civic Center Dr.

463: The Depot at Santa Ana - Hutton Centre via Grand Ave.

464: The Depot at Santa Ana - Costa Mesa via 5/55 Freeways/Sunflower Ave.

470: Tustin Metrolink Station - John Wayne Airport via Harvard Ave./Michelson Dr./MacArthur Blvd.

471: Tustin Metrolink Station - Irvine via Red Hill Ave./Jamboree Rd./Von Karman St.

480: Irvine Transportation Center - Lake Forest via Alton Pkwy./Bake Pkwy./Lake Forest Dr.

482: Irvine Transportation Center - Irvine Center & Discovery via Barranca Pkwy./Alton Pkwy.

490: Laguna Niguel/Mission Viejo Metrolink Station – Aliso Viejo via Crown Valley Pkwy./Moulton Pkwy./Aliso Creek Pkwy.

686: Irvine Transportation Center - Irvine Spectrum via Ada/Alton/Irvine Center/Fortune

693: San Clemente via Avenida Pico/Camino la Pedriza/Avenida Vista Hermosa

757: Pomona - Santa Ana Express via 57 Freeway

758: Chino - Irvine Spectrum Express via the 57/5 Freeways

794: Riverside/Corona - South Coast Metro Express via the 91/55 Freeway

Some alternatives to buses

Carpool: (800)COMMUTE or http://www.commutesmart.info ; also http://members6.boardhost.com/OCAngels/

Cabs: (949)654-8294 or http://www.octap.net

Posted by M at 19:47:01 | Permalink | No Comments »

Bus strike means a hard road for the working poor

Their struggle to get to jobs underlines Orange County’s disparities.
By Tony Barboza, Ashley Powers and Christian Berthelsen, Times Staff Writers
July 10, 2007

OCTA on Strike Routes in service during strike

Before sunrise Monday, his job running a sewing machine on the line, bus rider Andy Lee had little choice but to start walking. The 40-year-old walked from Anaheim to Garden Grove. He walked for so long he stopped for breakfast. By 8 a.m., he had been walking for more than two hours — with several miles still to go.


“Maybe I’ll have to buy a bicycle,” said an exasperated Lee, one of the thousands of desperate Orange County bus riders who responded to the first workday of the county’s bus strike by carpooling, bicycling or begging for rides.

Though bus drivers, who are seeking higher wages, walked out Saturday, it took the workweek to begin for the strike to deliver its wallop. Folks struggled to commute. Workers scrambled to find rides. Sensing profit in some people’s misfortune, enterprising motorists transformed their vans and trucks into bootleg taxicabs.

If anything, the bus strike, which shut down about 60% of the county’s routes, highlighted Orange County’s yawning gap between its wealthy and working class, between the haves and have-nots.

Many of the Orange County Transportation Authority’s 225,000 daily riders are telemarketers, fast-food workers, maids, landscapers and machine operators trying to eke out a living in a county whose median home price in May — $635,000 — was the highest in Southern California.

Two-thirds of county bus riders are Latino, about one-fifth are white and 72% don’t own a vehicle, according to a 2005 OCTA ridership survey. About half said they had annual household incomes of less than $20,000 — about $45,000 below the county’s median.

“Public transportation here is really a fringe element of society,” said Paul Stowell, 44, who was heading to a job interview Monday on one of the few operating bus lines. “You have the poor, the handicapped and people who lost their license.”

On Monday, transit and union officials both used the wage gap to jockey for the public’s backing.

Just as an OCTA press release said the agency was trying to offset a “major disruption” in its riders’ lives, union leadership countered with its own plea to the working poor:

“Currently, many drivers already qualify for housing assistance, and the board’s current offer only makes matters worse. OCTA wants to create poverty wages that are not in par with the cost of living in the region.”

County bus drivers last walked off the job in December 1986. That two-week strike ended after transit officials threatened to fire about 700 strikers — who protested to the tune of Christmas carols — days before the holiday.

This time, dozens of drivers waved signs that said “On Strike” or “Union Yes” outside a bus yard in Garden Grove. Amy Wilkerson, a union shop steward, said labor leaders were worried that drivers — whose average age is 48 — would be hit hard in retirement by healthcare costs.

“We feel very much for our passengers, but it’s not about them,” she said.

Negotiations between Teamsters Local 952 and OCTA resumed Monday, with federal and state mediators shuttling between the two teams. Two issues other than salary had halted talks: how that pool of money should be divvied up among workers and whether money budgeted to cover medical insurance costs but not needed would continue to supplement the drivers’ pension.

“We want to make sure all of our coach operators are compensated fairly,” said OCTA Chairwoman Carolyn Cavecche. “We have offered a very fair compensation package.”

Under the recently expired contract, a bus driver’s hourly wage ranges from $13.72 to $21.42, with top drivers pulling in about $60,000 a year. OCTA has offered a 13% increase for the three-year contract, but drivers are seeking 14%, saying their old agreement failed to keep pace with inflation. About half the drivers live in Orange County, about 10% in Los Angeles County and the remainder in the Inland Empire, union officials said.

The union hopes to concentrate raises among the more senior of its 1,100 drivers — a reward for allowing officials six years ago to boost new drivers’ pay. Transit officials, however, want to spread the raises more evenly — a necessary step, they argue, to woo drivers to a county with a high cost of living.

“We’re not against having higher starting wage or money going to junior people,” said Patrick D. Kelly, the union’s secretary-treasurer. “But we have to keep our commitment to the group, the senior people who bit the bullet six years ago.”

Another sticking point is funding for the drivers’ pension. Historically, OCTA used the leftover employee medical insurance money to augment it. But this year, the authority proposed changing the way that money is paid out, and labor leaders balked.

The drivers were set to strike in May, but Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger got a court-ordered injunction, which expired at midnight Friday.

“They are trying to bring working families to a level where they can survive,” said Ada Briceno, president of Unite Here Local 681, a hotel and restaurant workers union. “The strike is a necessary thing, and we back up our brothers in transportation.”

Thirty-one OCTA routes were open Monday on a limited basis. Supervisors operated one of its most heavily traveled lines, No. 43, which links Fullerton to Costa Mesa via Harbor Boulevard.

Aboard that bus, security guard Dan Sheehy, 59, headed to work in Garden Grove and lamented the $20 he had to fork over to an acquaintance for a ride home — the bus was to stop running at 6 p.m. That money equaled one-third of what he pockets for his shift.

“The vast majority of people who are driving their cars up and down the freeways know nothing about the bus,” he said. “It’s a kind of socioeconomic separation.”

Officials at St. Regis Monarch Beach in Dana Point, Newport Beach Country Club and other businesses that lean heavily on service workers said the strike resulted in few problems. At Disneyland, officials said the walkout had “minimal impact” because only 1% of its 20,000 employees ride the bus.

Many small-business owners, particularly in bus-reliant Santa Ana, did suffer — more for lack of customers than for absent employees. Hairdresser Maria Salazar walked several miles to her salon Monday, praying for more clients than the weekend’s few stragglers. Sam Romero, who owns a religious-goods shop, said weekend sales had plummeted 25%.

“I know my customers come on the bus because they are always asking for double bags, because they don’t just hop into a car,” he said.

Some people hitched rides with raiteros , who transformed their vehicles into makeshift taxicabs. Mario Ramirez, 44, abandoned his usual trips to Tijuana in favor of driving one man 10 miles, from Brea to Santa Ana, for $15.

David Trujillo, 39, asked the passengers he picked up on Beach Boulevard only for gas money, though he was loath to refuse tips. “I’ll give anyone a ride who gives me a few dollars,” he said in Spanish.

Although OCTA tacked up fliers announcing the strike at some stops, a few would-be riders lingered, staring down Chapman Avenue in Garden Grove for a bus that would never show.

“You’d better start walking, because the bus isn’t coming!” yelled Guadalupe Trego, 28, a supervisor at Carl’s Jr., to a student waiting at a corner. Trego had spent the morning traversing the county to pick up her employees.

“We that live close to work are lucky, but for those who live far away, they’re really going to hurt,” she said in Spanish. “We all need the bus, and we all need the money.”


tony.barboza@latimes.com

ashley.powers@latimes.com

christian.berthelsen@latimes.com

Times staff writers Jonathan Abrams, Jennifer Delson, Dave McKibben and Garrett Therolf contributed to this report.

Posted by M at 19:45:50 | Permalink | No Comments »